Student-Led Book Club Review Among the Hidden by Margaret Peterson…
Grimm’s Fairy Tales Book Discussion
One of my groups read Grimm’s Fairy Tales. Here are their thoughts!
Choose this book
SC: The name Grimm
JB: We were wandering through the library and we coudn’t find anything in the miscellaneous. So we went to the classics
SC: These were the originals of fairy tales and these weren’t as grim as the originals
JB: I think these were modified
CA: So that they could be read by kids
Favorite Fairy Tale
SC: I liked the one, I don’t know what’s called, I think it’s the Princess and the Lion and it was where the girl went and found the lion because her father had to give the daughter to the lion or he would die.
AM: It’s called the Lady and the Lion
SC: So she went and after they were married-the lion-
AM: He was an enchanted prince
SC: He turned into a dove because he touched fire light. I liked it because it was a cool story of lost love.
JB: My favorite story was Tom Thumb and I liked it because it was like this little man who was super cocky and adventurous and these robbers were trying to steal money from his dad. He was like, yeah, I’ll get it back, they took him (he sold himself to them)-he was a little man about the size of your thumb-he went into the stomach of a cow and a wolf got him and ate him out of the cow and the wolf died
SC: Wife killed him
JB: He had all his money
AM: Mine was also the Lady and the Lion. I don’t know, it told you that the lady was willing to do anything just to get her husband back. It was cool
CA: I liked Tom Thumb for the same reasons that Jason did.
Why Did the Author Write These Stories
JB: It said at the back of the book, it said that they wrote them for their son that died at birth and they never got to tell them to him.
SC: What you put out will come back in-karma
JB: Where there is downhill there will be an uphill
SC: Be careful what you wish for
JB: Don’t be greedy
CA: fulfill your side of the deal-the Princess and the Frog and the princess didn’t fulfill her side of the deal in the beginning
CA: 4 since some of the stories were really good and some were really bored
SC: 17 out 20
JB: 2.5 because it was repetitive and you knew what was going to happen
AM: 4 because I don’t want to give it the full number of stars because I don’t think all books are perfect.
Your thoughts on the Grimm’s Fairytales?